Review: Catechizing Our Children
In this small book the author makes the argument for teaching children the catechism regularly from a young age, quoting many well-known theologians as he goes along.
The author discusses the history and strengths of the catechism (specifically the Westminster Shorter Catechism), but it is when he writes about its structure and the way it can be used to present the whole gospel that his argument is the strongest. He is able to show how carefully it was compiled by faithful men in order to demonstrate how God’s plan for salvation fits together.
However, the danger comes in the way the book teeters on the edge of giving the impression that a thorough grasp of the catechism will in some way help to ensure that a child will be converted. The author is obviously aware that this is not the case and makes sure that he includes caveats, but the concern is that an uninformed reader could take away a wrong impression.
The other big concern is that suggested programmes for Sunday School suggest teaching the catechism in detail on a regular basis. For most Sunday Schools this would leave little time for teaching from the Bible—as a result the question has to be asked, which is more important, the words of man or the Word of God?
The book makes a good case, but in the end it presents an unbalanced argument and may only be helpful for teachers and preachers.
This review was first posted on GoodBookReviews.org. The site has been closed as of March 2019
A Few Characteristics of the Gospel of Mark November 15, 2019
According to tradition this Gospel was composed to satisfy the urgent request of the people of Rome for a written summary of Peter’s preaching in that city. However, this cannot mean that the information found in this book must be withheld from everybody living outside of the city limits of the capital. As is clear […]
A Letter to a Minister’s Wife November 12, 2019
The following is taken from the excellent Memoir of John H. Rice, W. H. Maxwell (Philadelphia; 1835), pp. 334-337 * * * Union Theological Seminary, Feb. 13th, 1828 My Dear Jane, I have a thousand times purposed to write to you, since your marriage; but have never yet seen the time when I could fulfil my intentions. […]