The Doctrine of the Holy Spirit

Testimonials

Submit your testimonial

1. 

   Marc Daniel Rivera (KristiyaKnow) – 24 April 2025

   George Smeaton’s The Doctrine of the Holy Spirit is a scholarly yet devotional treatment of one of the most often neglected doctrines in Christian theology. First published in 1882 and reissued by Banner of Truth in a beautifully bound and fully re-typeset 2016 edition, this volume is an essential contribution to pneumatology—the doctrine of the Holy Spirit—as it was historically understood and biblically grounded within the Reformed tradition.

   Smeaton, a prominent theologian of the Free Church of Scotland and professor of Exegetics at New College, Edinburgh, presents this work as the culmination of a lifetime of theological study. He was highly esteemed by his contemporaries for his theological acumen and reverent approach, and this volume justifies that reputation.

   Divided into three parts, the book begins with a thorough exegetical survey of the doctrine of the Holy Spirit in both the Old and New Testaments. Smeaton carefully traces the progressive unfolding of the Spirit’s identity and work from the earliest scriptural revelations to the dramatic outpouring at Pentecost. Far from treating the doctrine as peripheral, Smeaton asserts that “wherever Christianity has become a living power,” the Spirit’s role has been as central as justification by faith.

   The second division forms the theological core of the book, where Smeaton explores six key themes with clarity and conviction. He begins with the personality and procession of the Holy Spirit, defending the traditional Trinitarian view against modern depersonalization. He then examines the Spirit’s anointing of Christ, revealing the deep relationship between the Second and Third Persons of the Trinity. The Spirit’s role in inspiration and revelation affirms the divine origin of Scripture, while His regenerating work in believers highlights the transformative power of salvation. Smeaton also addresses the Spirit of holiness, framing sanctification within a Trinitarian context, and concludes with the Spirit’s ongoing work in the church.

   Smeaton warns against the “mischievous and misleading” notion that the church should no longer pray for fresh effusions of the Spirit. In doing so, he models a theology that is both intellectually robust and spiritually fervent.

   The final division is a historical survey tracing the doctrine from the apostolic age through the patristic, medieval, and Reformation periods. This portion demonstrates Smeaton’s mastery of church history. His overview is particularly useful for readers who want to understand how doctrinal convictions about the Holy Spirit evolved and were defended over time.

   The clarity and modesty of Smeaton’s style are worth noting. Though deeply learned, he avoids technical obscurity. His goal is not merely academic argumentation but the edification of the Church.

   Final thoughts:
   George Smeaton’s The Doctrine of the Holy Spirit is exceptional, and perhaps one of the best works I’ve read on the subject. Smeaton’s treatment is comprehensive yet accessible. If you want to deepen your understanding of the Holy Spirit’s work in redemptive history and personal experience, I highly recommend this volume!

2. 

   Richard C Ross – 17 July 2026

   Isn’t it the case, with any of the writings of those men with penetrating spiritual perception, that statements of truth tumble over one another, not only proving to be deep insights into the subject immediately under discussion but truths pertinent to many other branches of Scripture knowledge and theological investigations?

   In many cases the exegesis offered here differs from the conventional but rarely does the author fail to convince. In particular, I’d suggest pages 173ff illustrate the case in point; one notable instance among many in this valuable book; an instance which alone ought to persuade those unfamiliar with this book to ‘take and read’.

   As with the contributions of all great expositors, George Smeaton’s comments offer an almost continuous flow of matter for sermons, coming to the reader with a sense of urgency which will burn into the heart of any preacher and make us wish we could preach that truth now!

   Due to the age in which this book was written, there are many pages wasted on the present day reader: those (sometime far too long) sections dealing with individuals whose stars declined ages past and whose influence thankfully ran into the sands shortly afterwards. This redundancy also applies to by far the greater number of footnotes, which almost invariably refer either to inaccessible books or irrelevant individuals.

   One sad lack is any discussion, or even recognition, of the doctrine of ‘definitive sanctification’. I found no reference to this truth, let alone development of the vital doctrine. While there is sound teaching on progressive sanctification, it will be impossible to cast that aspect of the Holy Spirit’s activity in the full light of Scripture without setting it beside its Biblical counterpart.

   There are a few, though only a few, typesetting errors; an unfortunate example on page 253.

   Inevitably, not every paragraph is of equal usefulness; whether (too frequently) on account of historical irrelevance or (rarely) on account of the questionable views Smeaton advocates. In this category, I would include the stingingly harsh criticism of what the author (twice) refers to as the ‘rash and presumptuous’ errors of the ‘Plymouth Brethren’. I have no particular interest in defending the ‘Plymouth Brethren’ but I object to the author summarily dismissing the views he castigates in this connection, while offering no Biblical justification for his position; relying (most untypically for this author) merely on what in effect is ‘tradition’. It cannot be a valid defence of his curt treatment to suggest that this matter does not deserve more space and attention, when the rejection of it is made with such vehemence.

   In my opinion pages 256 – 267 offer by far the most valuable contribution of this undoubtedly imposing book – of course, nothing like these theologically aristocratic books are written today! What paupers we are! It seems all-too-often that present-day written theology is either ‘watered-down’ theological homeopathy or aridl, self-congratulatory ‘academic’, whose only purpose is to prove ‘I can do it too’! We might ‘stand on the shoulders’ of our highly esteemed forefathers in the faith – but it seem we do not! Pages 256-267 are the quintessence of the whole book; indispensable truths to be lodged in the heart of every preacher of the gospel. The doctrinal and biblical dynamic of the truths Smeaton propounds here have their existential evidence in the preaching of Whitefield, Edwards, Rowland, Williams, Lloyd-Jones and co. Oh, that every preacher would take these simple and simply vital principles deep into our hearts and minds.